If you’re after a fast, premium German hatchback that blends pace, practicality and all-weather confidence, there are few better contenders than the BMW M135, Volkswagen Golf R, Audi S3 and Mercedes A35 AMG. Each offers strong performance from a turbocharged 2.0 litre engine, four-wheel drive and the badge appeal that comes with a premium manufacturer. But how do they compare?
The BMW M135 delivers 300 horsepower and hits 60 mph in under five seconds. It is one of the most economical in this group in real-world driving, with mid-thirties mpg achievable. The steering is precise, the xDrive system is confident in all conditions, and the chassis is composed enough for enthusiastic back road driving. The looks are more subtle than aggressive, with a bluff front end that divides opinion, but the shadow line trims and M Sport detailing help it stand out. Inside, the cabin feels well made and intuitive, with a straightforward layout and an infotainment system that remains one of the best in class.
The Volkswagen Golf R sits at the top of the Golf range with 328 horsepower and even sharper performance, managing 0–60 mph in just over four seconds. On the road, it feels mature and controlled, making it a brilliant daily driver as well as a weekend fun car. Its appearance is conservative but clean, with quad exhausts and subtle R badges hinting at the power underneath. The interior is smart and minimal, although the touch-sensitive climate and infotainment controls can be frustrating to use on the move. Still, the materials feel good and the digital cockpit is crisp.
The Audi S3 is the most understated of the bunch. With 306 horsepower and quattro grip, it flies off the line and provides a secure, planted drive. The ride is slightly firmer than the Golf but not uncomfortable. Styling is sleek and low-key, with a clean front end and discreet side skirts. The S3’s interior stands out for build quality and tech layout. The virtual cockpit and central screen are easy to use, and the driving position feels spot on.
Then there’s the Mercedes A35 AMG. It brings flair with its aggressive grille, large wheels and sporty bumpers. The 306 horsepower engine sounds the most exciting and the drive is punchy, although it feels heavier and slightly less agile than the others. The cabin is a visual treat with sweeping screens, turbine-style vents and high-end materials. But while the tech is impressive, some features take a while to get used to and the ride quality can be less forgiving on poor roads.
Choosing between them is tough. The M135 is for those who value sharp handling and efficiency. The Golf R blends performance with everyday comfort. The S3 offers refinement and high-quality tech in a sleek package. The A35 brings drama and presence, with an interior that looks and feels luxurious. Then of course, the look and feel of a car play a personal choice for us all. Each car delivers in its own way. For me personally, it would be between the M135 and Golf R.
Leave a comment